October 15, 2026
"Thirty-six loaves of bread on the shelf and would not sell one of them because no one came in." That's how Robert Smythe described a bad weekday at Pastry Pants in an interview with The Phoenix, Swarthmore College's student paper. His bakery at 10 Park Ave. held its farewell sale on Saturday, Oct. 3.
The same interview has the detail that explains what's left now. On Saturdays, lines went out the door. Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Sunday were different: "often there were no people." When Pastry Pants opened, the Inquirer described Swarthmore as "a town devoid of its own bakery," and that's true again now. From Monday through Friday, bread comes in as daily deliveries to the Co-op's shelves. To buy a loaf from the person who baked it, you'll need to go to the Saturday morning farmers market in the borough lot on Park Avenue, which is the same morning that carried Pastry Pants. This year's market season ends Nov. 21.
Here's how the week looks now, one day at a time, plus what's coming to Park Avenue next.
According to the Philadelphia Inquirer's Oct. 7 report, Smythe gave three reasons for closing: rising ingredient costs, trouble hiring staff, and "a lack of predictable business during weekday hours." He never found a bread baker, so he was making the bread himself on top of running the shop. He described this summer as "very, very bad."
The location was part of the problem too. Smythe told The Phoenix that the heavy traffic on Chester Road runs alongside the downtown rather than through it. Drivers passing through "don't know that we're there, so every business has to be a destination." Students from the college, just across the tracks, came in less than he'd hoped. He told the paper he baked only three cakes for students the whole time he was on Park Avenue.
So Pastry Pants ran on one strong morning a week. It opened in the former Occasionally Yours space in May 2024, after that brunch spot closed in March 2024. Smythe told the Inquirer that the bakery and Celia Bookshop, which opened on Park Avenue in October 2025, made it feel like "there was an anchor to our downtown." He chose to close before the slow winter season so he could pay his staff and sell the equipment.
You can still find coffee and bread in Swarthmore on weekdays. What's missing is a counter where the baking happens on site.
Hobbs Coffee, 1 Park Ave. This is still the main downtown stop for a morning coffee. Its own site lists weekday hours of 7 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Swarthmore Co-op, 341 Dartmouth Ave. For a weekday loaf, the Co-op is the closest option. Its bakery department page lists daily breads from LeBus and Metropolitan, along with bagels, rolls, pies, cakes, cookies, and muffins. The Phoenix reports that Metropolitan Bakery, which supplies bread to the Co-op, has closed its Rittenhouse Square retail shop and now makes wholesale baked goods only. The Co-op also has a prepared-foods department with dishes made fresh each day.
Broad Table Tavern, 10 S. Chester Rd. The restaurant inside the Inn at Swarthmore serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Its menu includes a smoked salmon and bagel plate.
Kohlberg Coffee Bar, Swarthmore College. This one is easy to miss. The college's dining page says the coffee bar in Kohlberg Hall is open to the public. It serves locally roasted coffee and espresso with pastries, bagels, and pretzels baked locally each day. Fall and spring hours are Monday through Thursday, 8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., and Friday, 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. It's closed on weekends.
Smythe joked to The Phoenix about students afraid to "cross those scary train tracks" into town. For a weekday pastry, it can be worth crossing them in the other direction.
Saturday is when the bakers show up in person. The Swarthmore Farmers Market runs from 9 a.m. to noon in the Swarthmore Borough Parking Lot at 121 Park Ave. The 2026 season goes through Nov. 21, rain or shine. The organizers say it averages 19 vendors a week, with live music.
Two bakeries come every week: Big Sky Bread Co. from Wilmington and Kismet Bagels from Philadelphia. The others rotate by week of the month. Hank's Cinnamon Buns from West Chester and Cedar Creek Catering's baked goods come on the second, fourth, and fifth Saturdays. Cedar Creek also has prepared food every week. Market Day Canele comes on the first, third, and fifth Saturdays. Unruly Nature, a Delaware County granola maker, comes on the first and third. On first and third Saturdays you can also get coffee at the market from Pour Richard's Coffee & Distillery of Devon.
Here's the published schedule mapped onto the seven Saturdays left in the season:
| Saturday | Week of month | Bread and pastry vendors scheduled | Coffee at market |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oct. 10 | 2nd | Big Sky, Kismet, Hank's, Cedar Creek | No |
| Oct. 17 | 3rd | Big Sky, Kismet, Market Day Canele, Unruly Nature | Pour Richard's |
| Oct. 24 | 4th | Big Sky, Kismet, Hank's, Cedar Creek | No |
| Oct. 31 | 5th | Big Sky, Kismet, Hank's, Cedar Creek, Market Day Canele | No |
| Nov. 7 | 1st | Big Sky, Kismet, Market Day Canele, Unruly Nature | Pour Richard's |
| Nov. 14 | 2nd | Big Sky, Kismet, Hank's, Cedar Creek | No |
| Nov. 21 | 3rd | Big Sky, Kismet, Market Day Canele, Unruly Nature | Pour Richard's |
The table follows the vendor list's stated rotation. The market also posts a weekly update that can change things. The Oct. 10 update, for example, names Cedar Creek Catering among the scheduled vendors but doesn't mention Hank's. Check that update before you go if you're after one vendor in particular. The Oct. 10 market is also the season's last Kids Korner.
Hobbs Coffee opens at 8 a.m. on weekends, an hour before the market, so you can get coffee there before heading to the lot.
Sunday was one of the days Smythe said often brought no customers at all. On Sundays now, Hobbs is open from 8 a.m. to 3 p.m., the Co-op's bakery shelves are an option, and Broad Table Tavern serves breakfast at the Inn. Kohlberg Coffee Bar is closed on weekends.
The bigger change comes after the Nov. 21 market. That's the last Saturday of the 2026 season, and it's the last scheduled date on the vendor list for Big Sky and Kismet. After that, the Co-op's delivered bread is what's left downtown. This is the stretch Smythe called the slow winter season, the one he chose not to run through.
Pastry Pants showed that Saturday mornings carry downtown Swarthmore. The upcoming calendar adds a few events at other times of day:
Two Park Avenue storefronts are still open questions. No new tenant has been announced for 10 Park Ave. A few doors down, the Stylus Room is planned for the ground floor of 110 Park. The Inquirer reported in March that it would be a roughly 30-seat cocktail lounge and vinyl listening room that closes by 11 p.m. Owner Greg Hoy also said he planned a family-friendly weekend brunch timed to the farmers market. At the time, he was under contract for the building's only retail space, pending permits. The latest local coverage, a DELCO.Today piece updated in May, still described the lounge as coming, with no opening date.
Smythe told the Inquirer he hopes people can accept that "there is a responsible time to close things," and that he wants to be a cautionary tale in at least one sense. Until Nov. 21, Big Sky Bread Co. and Kismet Bagels are at 121 Park Ave. every Saturday from 9 a.m. to noon.
If you have a favorite morning stop in Swarthmore that we didn't mention, or you're wondering how downtown changes like these affect life on your block, Torrey and Sara would love to hear from you. You can reach Torrey Jenkins & Sara Fritz anytime.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Your Work Starts in the Fall
Here are three of the most common misconceptions we hear in Delaware County (and beyond).
We pride ourselves in providing personalized solutions that bring our clients closer to their dream properties and enhance their long-term wealth.